The Tesla Model Y finished last out of 109 models in Germany's latest TÜV roadworthiness report, with major defects found on 18.5% of examples brought in for their first mandatory inspection. That is nearly triple the 6.4% average for cars of the same age and up from 17.3% a year earlier, the second consecutive year the Model Y has placed bottom of the ranking.
The findings come from TÜV's analysis of 9.7 million mandatory inspections carried out between July 2025 and June 2026, with the sharpest comparisons drawn among roughly three-year-old cars coming in for their first check.
What inspectors found on the Model Y
Worn suspension joints were flagged on Model Ys 24 times as often as on comparable cars, and defective brake discs turned up on 3.4% of the electric SUVs against a 1% average for the age group. Front lighting also drew more complaints than usual.
No model in that age group has recorded a worse first-inspection result since the 2015 edition of the report.
Mileage offers only part of an explanation. The Model Ys had covered an average of 36,000 miles (58,000 km) by the time they were inspected, against 29,200 miles (47,000 km) for the average car in the group. That is higher than typical, but not enough on its own to account for a failure rate nearly three times the norm.
The Mazda MX-30 and MG4 results
The Mazda MX-30 recorded a 3% failure rate, placing third overall behind the Mazda CX-60 and Mercedes-Benz GLA. Its average mileage of 16,200 miles (26,000 km) was less than half the Model Y's, so the two results are not a like-for-like durability comparison.
The MG4 became the first car from a Chinese automaker to appear in the report and finished second from the bottom with a 16% failure rate, despite averaging only 23,000 miles (37,000 km). Inspectors flagged brake discs on 10.3% of MG4s, about ten times the average, and suspension defects were unusually common. The Tesla Model 3 sat just ahead of the MG4 at 12.5%, on an average of 34,200 miles (55,000 km).
EVs took three of the six vehicle classes in the report, yet also filled the bottom three places in the overall ranking. That split is the more useful signal for buyers: electric powertrains are not the problem, but wear items such as suspension components and brakes deserve a close look on a used EV.
Why the German result sits awkwardly with US reliability data
The Model Y's showing runs against its reputation in the United States, where Consumer Reports ranked it the most reliable new EV. That survey rests on owners reporting problems they have encountered, whereas TÜV inspectors can detect play in a suspension joint a driver has not noticed.
Consumer Reports' own data also separates new from used: Tesla finished last as a brand in its survey of five- to ten-year-old cars. For anyone shopping a three-year-old Model Y, the German inspection record is the more directly relevant evidence.
Which Model Y the results cover
The TÜV findings apply to the Model Y built before the Juniper refresh. The updated car's softer suspension and new frequency-selective dampers made it noticeably more comfortable on test, but whether that setup wears better will only become clear as those cars accumulate miles and reach their own first inspections.
What buyers should take from it
The practical lesson is that a pre-Juniper Model Y warrants a proper suspension and brake inspection before purchase, particularly given how far some examples have travelled in three years. The report does not establish that the Model Y is an unreliable car in the round; it shows that a specific set of wear components has been failing at an unusually high rate on German roads.
TÜV has not published a breakdown of how the Juniper cars are faring, since they are not yet old enough to appear in meaningful numbers.

