INDEPENDENT AUTOMOTIVE NEWSGLOBAL PERSPECTIVE / AUSTRALIAN EDITION
TDCNTHE DAILY
CAR NEWS.

The road ahead.
Every day.

RSS ↗
Latest/Electric

237 original articles

Electric / TDCN ORIGINAL

Volkswagen Group says its EVs earn less than combustion cars as nine-month margin hits 3.8 percent

CFO Arno Antlitz says growing electric demand is squeezing earnings, with a roughly €31 billion cost programme and up to 100,000 job cuts planned.

Image: Motor1

Volkswagen Group's finance chief has said openly that the company earns less on electric vehicles than on combustion-engine cars, and that rising EV sales are adding to the pressure on earnings. Arno Antlitz, chief financial officer and chief operating officer, made the admission alongside the group's nine-month results.

The group's operating return on sales after nine months stood at 3.8 percent, Antlitz said, meaning less than €4 of operating profit remains from every €100 of sales revenue. He described that as not enough in the long term.

Antlitz framed the problem as a consequence of the group's own sales success. "The market success of our electric vehicles is putting additional pressure on our earnings, because we currently earn less from electric vehicles than from combustion-engine vehicles," he said in a statement accompanying the results.

Volkswagen has not disclosed the size of the gap between EV and combustion-car profitability. The 3.8 percent figure covers the group as a whole, so the per-vehicle difference between the two powertrain types has not been announced.

The group's own wording makes the pressure structural rather than temporary: it must keep investing heavily in its electric line-up while competing on price in a difficult global market. Every buyer who picks an EV over a petrol or diesel model can mean one fewer sale of a more profitable vehicle, and factories built around combustion engines risk running below capacity.

Why more electric sales do not fix the problem

Selling more EVs is not optional for the group. It needs the volume to bring down fleet-wide CO₂ emissions and avoid potentially hefty fines for missing EU regulatory targets. That leaves it selling more of the less profitable product to stay compliant.

There is genuine demand to build on. EVs made up 40 percent of the group's order book in Europe through the first nine months of the year, and its Electric Urban Car Family has drawn around 150,000 orders. The VW ID. Polo, VW ID. Cross, Cupra Raval and Skoda Epiq are named as important parts of the push to expand electric mobility in Europe.

The next test is affordability. The production version of the ID. Every1 concept is due in 2027 and could revive the ID. Up nameplate as the brand's cheapest electric car. A lower price should widen access to EV ownership, but it also leaves thinner margins on each car, which makes building an affordable EV profitably a harder problem than selling expensive ones at a loss.

China, tariffs and Chinese pricing in Europe

Other headwinds are compounding the squeeze. The group points to a sharply shrinking Chinese market, increasingly aggressive pricing by Chinese automakers in Europe, and U.S. tariffs, all of which make margin improvement harder across its brands.

Its answer is a broad cost programme worth around €31 billion. Priorities include simplifying the model range, streamlining organisational structures, lowering vehicle costs and overheads, improving factory efficiency and speeding up technology development.

The restructuring reaches the product plan and the workforce. As many as 50 percent of models could eventually be retired, and the group plans to simplify its parts bin sharply to improve economies of scale. The long-running SEAT brand could be phased out, though no final decision has been made. Around 100,000 job cuts worldwide are targeted.

Four German plants, Emden, Zwickau, Hanover and Neckarsulm, have no guaranteed production allocations beyond 2031 to 2034. The group says it is evaluating alternative uses for the sites rather than announcing closures, but further shutdowns or production cuts remain possible as it works to cut costs and excess capacity.

"We cannot afford to lose any time. We must act quickly and decisively," Antlitz said.

What it means for buyers

For drivers, the near-term effect is a group pushing hard on price to keep EV orders coming, particularly in Europe, where the 40 percent EV order share and the 150,000 orders for the urban electric family give it a base to defend. The models named for that push, the ID. Polo, ID. Cross, Cupra Raval and Skoda Epiq, are the ones to watch for how aggressively that pricing is set.

The longer-term risk sits in the cost programme itself. A simplified range, a slimmed parts bin and a possible SEAT exit change what is on sale, and the four German plants without allocations past the early 2030s leave open where future models will be built. None of those decisions has been finalised beyond the model and job-cut targets.

Open this article ↗
Electric / TDCN ORIGINAL

UK Budget raises company car tax on EVs and PHEVs from April 2030

Electric company car drivers will see Benefit-in-Kind rates climb from 4% to 10%, while some plug-in hybrids jump to 20%, prompting fleet industry criticism.

The UK government's Autumn Budget has confirmed that company car tax rates will rise across the board in April 2030, with electric vehicles facing the steepest increases and plug-in hybrids losing the range-based incentives they once enjoyed.

For fleet operators and company car drivers, the changes mean Benefit-in-Kind (BiK) bills will climb sharply, and industry specialists say the Chancellor missed a chance to make used electric company cars more affordable.

How the new BiK rates break down

Company car drivers pay BiK on the perk of using a vehicle for private journeys, taxed at their income rate, typically 20% or 40%. Since 2002 the taxable value has been calculated as a percentage of list price across 27 bands ranging from 4% to 37%, with higher prices and CO2 emissions attracting higher charges.

The Budget confirmed all rates will rise by one percentage point in April 2030, but electric vehicles face the steepest climb: from 4% in 2026/27 to 10% in 2030/31. For a 20% taxpayer in a Volkswagen ID 3 Style with the 79kWh battery, that means monthly BiK bills rising from £27 to £67.

Plug-in hybrids fare worse. The 2024 Budget removed incentives for vehicles emitting 1-50g/km CO2 to offer a longer electric range, placing them all into a single 18% band. A Volkswagen Golf eHybrid with an 88-mile electric range will rise from 7% BiK today to 20% in 2030/31, with monthly BiK tripling from £44 to £133.

Three quarters of company car drivers currently pay BiK on a vehicle under 50g/km, according to the latest HMRC data. That concentration of drivers in the low-emission bands means the rate rises will touch a large share of the fleet market, not just a niche group of early EV adopters.

Fleet specialists say the Budget falls short

Dave Bushnell, director of consultancy and strategy at Fleet Operations, welcomed the announcement as a step towards restoring confidence but said it could go further.

"We're disappointed that the Chancellor hasn't taken this opportunity to make used electric company cars more affordable," he said. "Drivers are still taxed on a vehicle's original list price, even when it has depreciated significantly. Changing this could have opened up electric cars to more employees through salary sacrifice schemes, while also helping to boost demand in the second-hand market and support residual values".

The used-car point is the sharpest criticism in the industry response. Because BiK is pinned to original list price rather than current value, a depreciated EV can carry a tax bill out of proportion to what it is actually worth, which weakens the case for salary sacrifice schemes built around second-hand electric cars.

Capital allowances and mileage rates also change

The Budget confirmed changes to Capital Allowances, which let businesses offset investment costs against gross profits and reduce corporation tax. For cars the system is CO2-based: businesses can offset 100% of the cost of zero-emission cars (electric and hydrogen), falling to 14% for vehicles emitting 1-50g/km and 6% for anything above that threshold.

The 14% main rate was cut from 18% in April 2026 and will fall to 12% in April 2027, effectively reducing the tax breaks for businesses buying plug-in hybrids in that bracket. Tax breaks for leased cars are unchanged, with businesses able to offset 100% of monthly rental costs for vehicles emitting 50g/km CO2 or less.

Businesses running a grey fleet will also face rising costs. HMRC's approved mileage rate lets employees claim back the cost of driving their own car for work, covering fuel, depreciation, wear and tear and other operating costs. The initial rate was temporarily raised from 45p to 55p per mile in June and will now become permanent, while the higher-mileage rate rises from 25p to 35p. Those are the first changes in 15 years and are expected to support three million employees who use their own car for work, according to the Treasury.

Jon Lawes, managing director at Novuna Vehicle Solutions, said: "With manufacturers facing intense global competition and pressure on residual values, the priority must be a transition that customers can afford and businesses can plan for. Greater certainty on EV taxation, charging costs and future sales targets will be critical to sustaining demand, protecting used-car values and supporting long-term investment in the UK motor industry".

The mileage rate increase is the one measure in the Budget that clearly eases costs for drivers, but it applies to those using their own cars for work rather than to company car drivers facing higher BiK. For fleets weighing up electric options, the combined effect is a steeper tax trajectory for EVs and PHEVs alongside narrower capital allowance relief for plug-in hybrids.

Open this article ↗

Keep scrolling to read the next story.

Older articles →